As a doctor I deal with this coming up constantly. Patients want “tests” but don’t understand pre test probability. They can perceive the denial of testing when pre test probability is low as some sort of conspiratorial oppression. I often also have trouble getting trainees comfortable with commenting on different degrees of uncertainty.
Even medical school graduates constantly get biostatistical questions wrong on the boards.
And all doctors are affected by the availability bias and wind up doing testing that’s overwhelmingly negative. Hence why healthcare is expensive.
There really should be an international competition for explaining Bayes and we can get this over with. Just copy the explanation to a poster in every waiting room and med school hallway.
My best attempt for testing is to take 50 lego-sized figurines and say okay one person has the disease in here. If I test five and one gets a false positive, look at how they pile up before I get to the one real case. Then divide the 1 over all the rest. In extreme cases, it's a gigantic pile.
Thank you for this! We could put the poster in high schools too. That's a longer task but I'm up for it.
As a doctor I deal with this coming up constantly. Patients want “tests” but don’t understand pre test probability. They can perceive the denial of testing when pre test probability is low as some sort of conspiratorial oppression. I often also have trouble getting trainees comfortable with commenting on different degrees of uncertainty.
Even medical school graduates constantly get biostatistical questions wrong on the boards.
And all doctors are affected by the availability bias and wind up doing testing that’s overwhelmingly negative. Hence why healthcare is expensive.
There really should be an international competition for explaining Bayes and we can get this over with. Just copy the explanation to a poster in every waiting room and med school hallway.
My best attempt for testing is to take 50 lego-sized figurines and say okay one person has the disease in here. If I test five and one gets a false positive, look at how they pile up before I get to the one real case. Then divide the 1 over all the rest. In extreme cases, it's a gigantic pile.
Thank you for this! We could put the poster in high schools too. That's a longer task but I'm up for it.